|
Indirect Subsidies
Indirect subsidies are paid by consumers through high prices at the pump. The
USDA found that between 1982 and 2006 the wholesale price of ethanol averaged
57¢ more than the wholesale price of gasoline (USDA 2007c). The average
subsidy during that period was 54¢. From the blender's perspective, after the
subsidy, the price of ethanol was just 3¢ more than the cost of gasoline.
Apparently there is a strong tendency for the price of ethanol to equal the
price of gasoline, but something is giving the ethanol price a little boost.
Although it may seem obvious that ethanol and gasoline
would sell for the same price per gallon, the USDA's chief economist points
out that with more supply, the premium could "decline toward ethanol’s energy
equivalent with gasoline." (USDA, 2007) In other words, Collins is saying that
in a balanced market, ethanol and gasoline will tend to sell for the same
price per energy, not the same price per gallon. That seems reasonable since
it's energy that powers a car, and not just gallons .
But the USDA found that for the last 25 years there was no
tendency towards this balance. Ethanol and gasoline have sold at the same
price per gallon (after subtracting the subsidy) and not at the same price per
energy. Ethanol selling at the same price per energy as $2.00 gasoline would
not sell at $2.00 per gallon but at $1.33 per gallon. At $2.00 per gallon,
ethanol is getting a 67¢ price subsidy simply because its lack of energy is
ignored by the market.
Why does the market make this mistake? First, consumers
often don't know they are buying the ethanol--it's just blended in for smog
control. Second, they have no choice because all the gasoline has it included.
Third, very few people know it has less energy. These market anomalies are the
source of the mis-pricing and the primary source of ethanol's indirect
subsidy. In 2006, because of the MTBE phaseout and the switch to ethanol as an
additive, wholesale ethanol sold (after subtracting the subsidy) for 13¢ more
per gallon than gasoline. This added to the subsidy from mis-pricing.
In 2006, the effective wholesale
price of ethanol, after subtracting the blender's subsidy, was 80¢ higher than
the price of gasoline with the same energy content, hence the indirect subsidy
to ethanol, paid at the pump, was 80¢ per gallon of ethanol.
|
|